Swamp Thing 18

swamp thing 18 ROT

Today, Shelby and Scott are discussing Swamp Thing 18, originally released March 6th, 2013. This issue is part of the RotWorld crossover event. Click here for complete RotWorld coverage. 

Shelby: I’m going to be honest with you all: I’m at a loss, here. I’m not sure where to begin. Swamp Thing has been one of my favorite titles since I picked it up around issue 6. Scott Snyder’s Alec Holland is a conflicted man, trying to find his place in the world, but ultimately following his heart. Yanick Paquette’s art is horrifyingly beautiful, so beautiful I was inspired to permanently ink it into my skin. Add a couple star-crossed lovers, disgusting zombie creatures, and the destruction of the DC universe, and you’ve got something pretty special on your hands. This issue marks the end of Rotworld, the end of Snyder and Paquette’s work on the title, and the fates of Abby and Alec; it’s no wonder I’m feeling a little bittersweet about this write-up. 

After jumping into the Rot, Alec is deposited at Anton’s castle with just enough time to prevent Abby’s de-spineification, which he does with alacrity.

alec and anton

Abby and Alec know that even being torn in half isn’t enough to stop Anton. The only way to take him out for good is by revoking his avatar card, which the Parliament of Rot can only do if Abby takes his place, which she can only do if she is dead. So, Alec takes her in his arms one more time, and kills her. Anton bursts in and proceeds to beat the shit out of Alec. As his human form begins to die and his Swamp Thing form begins to receed, Abby reappears as the Avatar of the Rot, and truly destroys Anton.

Alec wakes up back in the swamp with his Parliament; he is now truly Swamp Thing, with no nugat-y human center. Abby comes to say good-bye, and she brings the saddest gift in the world: her and Alec’s bodies. Swamp Thing grows a beautiful bed of flowers over Alec and Abby, and embraces his love one last time.

alec and abby say goodbye

Even though technically he can put down roots and be a member of the Parliament now, Swamp Thing decides it would be dumb to waste this second chance at life he’s been given, and is ready to take on whatever the world can throw at him.

What a beautiful conclusion to Alec’s part of Rotworld. Even though my heart is broken, I can’t deny the power of the closure Snyder has given to Alec and Abby. Think about it: there has really only been one arc in Swamp Thing, this is the end of a story that has been about a year and a half in the making. The heroes sacrifice themselves in order to save the world. The ill-fated lovers can never be together. The villain is vanquished, our heroes redeemed. It’s all pretty simple stuff, but Snyder has used these basic ideas very elegantly to conclude the story of Alec and Abby.

As gorgeous as Snyder’s writing is, though, it’s not what has got me in tears as I write this. In the comments of Swamp Thing 17, Mr. Paquette mentioned that he wasn’t on art duty because he was focusing on the art for this issue, and it shows. If I could show you every page of this issue I would, and I would have something to say about every panel, but I think the image to best portray Paquette’s stunning work is Abby’s death at Alec’s hand.

abby's death

How can something like that not break your heart? Look at the anguish on Alec’s face, the beauty of the branches piercing Abby’s body! Paquette also is calling on a lot of visual themes from earlier issues throughout this book; the shape of the border around the panel, for instance, mirrors the trippy cover to Swamp Thing 7while the color scheme preps us for Abby’s new appearance. Her new look is a less monsterish version of her as the Rot Queen in Swamp Thing 9But the cherry on top of the sundae of this image is the handful of Abby’s orchids, growing on the end of the branches on which she is impaled. The flowers look forward to her rebirth as the Avatar of the Rot, while looking back to her origin as the Rot-wielding badass she is. It’s smart, poignant, and gorgeous in a bittersweet sort of way. As badly as I am going to miss Snyder on this title, Paquette is the one I’m really sad about.

Last month Patrick expressed some concern over the implications of the time travel reset. He was worried that Rotworld would turn from a “this is what happened” to  a “what if?” scenario. That is definitely not the case; I don’t think I’m out of line in saying that Alec’s main reason for going back was to save Abby, not to save the world. Well, he went back, and she had to die anyway, and not only did she still die, but Alec died, too. Rotworld has had a lasting effect on these characters and this universe, despite the fact that technically it never actually happened. Snyder gave us the closure we needed and delivered a universe reset, all without depreciating the impressions Rotworld has left.

Mr. Snyder and Mr. Paquette, your work on this title has been phenomenal: thank you. I look forward to, in the future, picking up and becoming obsessed with anything that has either of your names on it.
Scott: Well said, Shelby. Paquette’s art truly is something to behold. It’s amazing that my immediate and lasting impression of this issue is that it looks beautiful, considering how much page space is occupied by ugly beasts impaling each other with massive claws and branches. But there’s even beauty in the bloodspatter.

Pretty, gross

The beauty of the artwork also distracts from the fact that this is an incredibly sad story. Not only does Alec have to kill Abby by his own hand, he then has to see her again as the Avatar of the Rot and confront the fact that they can never be together. Somehow, those are both the most heartbreaking thing that could have happened.

Shelby, you mentioned that Paquette took last month off to focus on this issue, and I’m grateful for that. This issue had a fairly simple story, but it was jam-packed with emotional moments that hardly had time to develop, and it relied on the art to sell the drama. Consider the conversation Alec and Abby have right before her death. Abby is trying to convince Alec to kill her — probably the most unthinkable scenario Alec could ever be presented with — yet the entire conversation, from when the subject is broached to Abby’s actual death, lasts only maybe 20 seconds of real time. That’s it. With so much else to cover  in so few pages, Snyder has no time to linger on this one beat. Paquette’s heart-stopping art manages to draw out the scene, making it feel slower, weightier and more intense, like the grand emotional moment it really is. With lesser art, this sequence would have felt rushed and unsatisfying.

It’s interesting that our discussion has been so centered upon this issue being the last by Snyder and Paquette, rather than it being the last issue of RotWorld. I suppose, RotWorld or not, this was the conclusion Snyder and Paquette needed to reach before passing the baton. But it feels more like the end of a series than the end of an event. RotWorld was an adequate facilitator of events that were bound to happen, but it didn’t alter the course of the ship. Still, Swamp Thing 18 neatly tied up Snyder’s major arcs, ending with a literal rebirth of the character.  Charles Soule and Kano will take over Swamp Thing, with unlimited possibilities of where to take the series. Swamp Thing 18 was a stunning farewell to a beloved creative team; whether the series gets better or worse, Snyder and Paquette will be missed.

For a complete list of what we’re reading, head on over to our Pull List page.  Whenever possible, buy your comics from your local mom and pop comic bookstore.  If you want to rock digital copies, head on over to DC’s website and download issues there.  There’s no need to pirate, right?

19 comments on “Swamp Thing 18

  1. What an ending. I feel foolish for ever having even the slightest doubt that Snyder & Lemire wouldn’t stick the landing. While Animal Man had a gutpunch of an ending, Swamp Thing ended on a much more melancholic note. SwampThing was heartbreaking while Animal Man is heart-wrenching. The conclusions were both extremely satisfying.

    Swamp Thing has been my favourite book of the New52 (and, with Saga, my favourite comic I am reading right now) so I am very sad to see the end of Snyder & Paquette’s run. I am curious to see where Soule/Kano will take the character but it will be tough for them to live up to this. Thankfully, the story was left in such a way that they will be able to easily pick up and take it in a new direction.

    Any word on what Paquette will be working on next? I can’t seem to find any news on what he’ll be doing.

    • I’ve heard he’s doing a Wonder Woman Year One book with Grant Morrison. Obviously I’ll pick up anything Paquette has laid hands on.

      I just can’t get over how perfect the endings to both these books were. Honestly, this particular issue is something that will stick with me for a long while.

      • I don’t know what to say about this that you haven’t already said. This was such a heartbreakingly beautiful book and the loss of its creators will be felt.

      • Yeah, I think we only saw that power demonstrated under the TERRIFYING PENCILS of Francesco Francavilla. I like the idea that Paquette was like “oh, we’re not finishing this shit without me getting a chance to draw that.”

  2. Can we talk for a second how how cool this as a new / not-really-new status quo for Swamp Thing? He’s back to being a Swampy Thing full-time, with no trace of human being at the core AND, as an added bonus, has all of Alec Holland’s memories, there also exists a dead body of Alec Holland floating about. He’s not no connection to anything, just the Green and the Parliament. I’m really looking forward to seeing some shorter adventures of Swamp Thing defending the Green in less abstract terms – like stopping loggers or polluting or something.

    • Yeah, I think a return to that kind of classic “ecological defender” (with a mix of horror) status quo could be the best way to move forward with this title. Even without this awesome creative team, I’m really excited for next month’s issue.

  3. What do you think about the Parliament’s statement that they’ve got another avatar in the works, but that “she’s not ready yet”? My first thought was obviously Poison Ivy, any other ideas?

    • Ivy was also my thought. It’s interesting that both the Red and the Green have these like second tier champions (in the form of Beast Boy and Poison Ivy, respectively), but there’s also Black Orchid, who is kinda both Red and Green (and per John Constantine’s notes, part of Project Ascention – whatever that means). So I don’t know what to make of who else that “she” could be but Poison Ivy.

      You think there’s any reason the Parliaments would be ceding power to these mini-champions? Like if they have some kind of secret agendas that they can’t leave to their actual avatars?

  4. What a gorgeous issue and an excellent ending. That panel of Abby’s death is so beautiful I’d get it painted life-size on a wall in my house if I had the money to, it’s just so haunting. I will sorely miss this creative team, though as has been pointed out, they exit on a wonderful note. I’ll give the new team a shot though, the ending here suggests intersting possibilities for the future, while also harkening to the past as it re-establishes a full-vegetation Swamp Thing à-la Alan Moore.

    Lastly, I also thought of Ivy at the mention of a female avatar, but I have just one hope. Either make Ivy the new avatar sometime down the line, or create a character vastly different from her to take the mantle, I would have to see some stupid knockoff (Venomous Lily?) be just like Ivy but named different for the sake of leaving Pam to Batman’s playing field.

  5. Pingback: Superman 17 | Retcon Punch

  6. Pingback: Best of 2013: Best Issues | Retcon Punch

  7. Pingback: Swamp Thing 27 | Retcon Punch

What you got?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s