Best of 2014: Best Artist

Best of 2014: Best ArtistWithout artists, all of your favorite characters, scenes, costumes, and locations would just be words on a page. In short, they’re the ones that make comics comics. That’s a lot of responsibility, yet the best artists manage to juggle all of those tasks and inject some meaningful art and style into the proceedings. Whether its a subtle expression or a jaw-dropping action sequence, our favorite artists add the requisite magic to make their worlds and characters real. These are our top 14 artists of 2014.

14. Fiona Staples

This year’s arc of Saga started with telling us that Marko and Alana — the central couple we’d all spent the previous 18 issues pulling for — would split up. It turns out that may not be the whole story, but that presumption gave Staples plenty of space to shade in a slowly disintegrating marriage. Staples has always had an eye for just the right expression, but the smaller, domestic drama of this arc put those skills front and center, showing off just how impeccable her acting truly is.

Saga Acting

13. Francis Manapul

2014 found Manapul pulled in some new directions, as he traded in the bright optimism of the Gem Cities for the shadowy grime of Gotham. We never doubted that his Detective Comics would look great, but we didn’t quite expect the noirish details that started creeping in at the fringes. A dramatic lighting cue or canted camera angle goes a long way to differentiating his work here from is art on The Flash (which we also loved), giving the series a mood that was distinctly its own. He’d always been a great director, but this year showed that he can do “detective procedural” just as well as he does “action thriller.”

Detective Directing

12. Nick Dragotta

The world of East of West is massive — a given issue could feature any (or all) of the seven nations, each with their own distinct style of dress and architecture. Dragotta manages to juggle all of these details — plus whatever monsters or technologies don’t fit within those seven nations — all without losing his own signature look that so defines the series. This year found the factions of the series butting heads, making Dragotta’s designs all the more important to understanding the conflicts at play, whether they be those between old world and new, north and south — even east and west.

East of West

11. Steve Epting

Exotic locations, huge action set-pieces, seduction, intrigue. These are the spectacles we expect of a spy thriller, but in the case of Velvet all of those production values fall on the shoulders of Epting. Fortunately, Epting’s range covers every situation this series can throw at him, from a stealthy extraction mission to the baccarat tables of Monaco. Epting’s flair for dramatic shadows give every scene the look of a classic spy thriller, codifying our expectations just before the blot subverts them. It’s a clever effect the series has relied on again and again, but only works because Epting sells it so perfectly.

Baccarat Table

10. Jamie McKelvie

Choice of moment is a key skill for a comic book artist, and it might just be Jamie McKelvie’s strongest. That’s not to say that he’s a slouch when it comes to staging, blocking, character design, or acting — indeed, he can hang with the best when it comes to any of those skills — but that they’re all enhanced because he always manages to select the right expression and posture to convey all of the emotion and momentum that his stories call for. It makes him just as adept with talking heads as he is with an action sequence, which might just be why Kieron Gillen likes collaborating with him so much.

Wicked and Holier than thou

9. Russell Dauterman

It was a banner year for Dauterman, who kicked things off with a stellar two-issue stint pencilling Kyle Higgins’ emotional farewell to Nightwing. From there Dauterman pencilled the beautiful first arc of Cyclops, before being tapped to headline with Jason Aaron on his new volume of Thor. As if vaulting to one of Marvel’s premiere titles wasn’t enough, that new volume featured a controversial new female character wielding Mjolnir. Dauterman’s gorgeous art transcended that controversy, crackling with all the confidence of a newly minted star in the comics world.


8. Andrea Sorrentino

Sorrentino and Lemire shook up Green Arrow in 2013, jettisoning virtually everything in that series that wasn’t absolutely central, and changing many things that were. 2014 found them setting their sights even higher, as they embarked on their epic “Outsiders War”, building on their own mythology, and upending even more assumptions about the series. After wrapping up that run this summer, Sorrentino’s skills at slowing down a scene to bullet time became the central motif of his dual X-Men annuals, as Sorrentino imbued Eva Bell’s secret history with all of the style and maturity he brought to Green Arrow.


7. Chris Samnee

From smartphones to door signs, the past two volumes of Daredevil have been full of little reminders of Matt’s blindness — important reminders of the value of a sense we might otherwise take for granted. That raised awareness of sight pairs beautifully with Samnee’s nuanced art, which is so subtle as to be easily taken for granted, too. Samnee’s style is deceptively simple, but don’t let the efficacy of his bold lines confuse just how much storytelling he packs into every panel. The first issue of the new volume is a standout, establishing the who, what, where, and why of Daredevil into 20 breathtaking pages.

Daredevil in a nutshell

6. Cliff Chiang

Chiang’s intelligent, mature storytelling had long made him the perfect fit for the equally intelligent and mature Wonder Woman, but as Chiang and Brian Azzarello’s three-year long epic accelerated into its conclusion, Chiang was tasked with ever more superlative images — from the most chaotic battle to the most emotionally wrenching reunion. That he was able to deliver is a testament to his skills, but more impressive is that his art got even better as the end approached, wringing even more depth and meaning out of every line.

Wonder Woman

5. Greg Capullo

Batman is routinely one of the biggest sellers in all of comicdom, so between sales numbers, fan expectations, and over 75 years of history, there is plenty of ideals for the creative team to live up to. Add to that the treacherousness of a brand-new continuity (to change too much is sacrilege, to change too little is boring), and you have a veritable tightrope act on top of trying to tell a meaningful story. Impossibly, Capullo blows all of those expectations out of the water every single month. This year in particular found Capullo recreating some of the most iconic Batman images, yet somehow retaining his own style and sensibilities, emphasizing the “by fans, for fans” feel that makes this creative team so exciting.

The Dark Knight

4. David Aja

David Aja’s dense, incredibly graphic style has come to represent everything that’s so compelling about Hawkeye, and the uniquely damaged character of Clint Barton. It may have been a slower year for the series (Aja only did the artwork for three issues, along with a couple pages in the holiday issue), but every single page is loaded with visual information. It is fitting, then, that it all drove toward the famous ‘deaf issue’, which took the idea of having to express thoughts visually to its often frustrating conclusion. What could have felt like a gimmick — albeit, a meaningful gimmick — actually reveals itself to be a perfect fit for the talent Aja’s displayed since the very first issue.

Hawkguy down on his luck

3. Chip Zdarsky

Sex Criminals tends to keep a lot of balls in the air. (Pause for snickering.) The second arc moved away from strictly being about the sexual confessions of our protagonists and out into the world of intimate confessions of everyone around them. Layers upon layers of therapy, fighting, disease, mistrust, and memories half-remembered and half-imaged stack up to tell emotionally coherent stories that — by all rights — should be absolutely dizzying to the eye. Zdarsky funnels the mad wit of Matt Fraction through a lens so personable, funny and clear that every single moment lands, even when the emotional revelations are popping in every panel. Tragedy can shift perspective all it wants, Zdarsky’s got his eyes fixed on the tragedy.

Robert Rainbow or Jon's tragedy

2. Mateus Santolouco

When it comes to depicting action on the still page, Mateus Santolouco is a master-craftsman. And action is Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles‘ bread and butter. Once our heroes returned from Northampton (an arc that we loved, but was much more quiet and subdued), it was time to kick back and have some fun, for crying out-loud. Santolouco borrowed some of Sophie Campbell’s more charming character details and set to the hugely gratifying business of pitting mutant animals against each other. Every page is packed with personality, movement and weight.

Nobody fights Bebop

1. Declan Shalvey

Declan Shalvey’s work on Moon Knight proved that a character could be completely, 100% comic booky and meaningfully interact with a more realistic word, without trivializing either. Moon Knight’s totally white design made him one with the gutter, a literal and transparent part of the page. Each of Shalvey’s six issues are absolutely breathless, ably expressing what’s so compelling about a character that simply cannot be expressed any other way. Shalvey never lets the core simplicity of the issues — Moon Knight rescues a child, Moon Knight fights punk rock ghosts, Moon Knight trips on mushrooms — diminish the intricacy of detail he brings to every page. It is at once graphic, simple, complex and completely mesmerizing.

Moon Knight coming from the gutter to kick your ass

Want more Best of 2014 lists? Check out our Best CoversBest Colorist, and Best Issue lists!


8 comments on “Best of 2014: Best Artist

  1. This was the hardest category for me. There are just so many fantastic artists I couldn’t even begin to narrow it down: there were like 30 different options I wanted to get on the lists. I think, ultimately, McKelvie, Manapul, and Dauterman were my tops (as always), but there are just so many great options…I know Mike Del Mundo, Michael Dialynas, and Patrick Gleason were on my ballot among with a bunch of others, but I can’t quibble one bit with anybody on this ballot. All are fantastic, I just wish we had room to talk about more haha.

    • Oh yeah, it’s basically an impossible task. For as much as comics gobble up stories as an alarming rate, the amount of art that’s produced for these things is absolutely staggering – meaning that the number of amazing artists has to be higher than the number of amazing writers. It’s still so backwards to me the way creator-celebrity works: we should always be worshiping the artists more than we do. Always.

      • Yep. I’ve been spouting the old “without artists, comics would just be books” line today, but really, they have the most control over what the final feel of the book is. I don’t totally buy into auteur theory, but it seems to me that we should hold comic book artists in no less esteem than we do film directors — which is to say, they should definitely getting more praise and recognition than they do.

  2. This one’s hard for me every time, because I can’t quite gauge how I’m supposed to weigh comparatively prolific interior work against eye-popping cover work, etc. I’ll just kind of split them into groups.

    Favorite interiors: Ivan Reis (my number one pick again), Greg Capullo, Cliff Chiang, Cameron Stewart, Matt Martin, Mikel Janin, Frank Quitely, George Perez, Mike McKone, Andrea Sorrentino

    Favorite covers: John Cassaday, Alex Ross, Darwyn Cooke, Amanda Conners, Ryan Sook

    • I tend to think of this category as being about the interiors, but we should probably be more explicit about it. It took me a long time to figure out what actually makes someone a good interior artist (which it turns out is very different than just drawing well), but I definitely stand by the storytelling skills of everyone on this list. It might be worth considering doing a best cover artist category in addition to the best covers list.

      • Yeah, that’s a really good point – I think everyone is on this list because of their skills as visual sequential storytellers. I think a lot of the strongest are also excellent at covers (like Capullo or Aja or Chiang), but the list’s premium is on storytelling.

        Like, maybe it’s interesting to note how high Santolouco is on this list, but the TMNT cover that we ranked is a Ross Campbell joint. Ultimately, lots of different artists do a lot of things well, so maybe this is just an exercise is gushing over artists we like?

    • Just realized that I accidentally credit War Stories’ cover artist Matt Martin when I actually intended to bigup the interior artist Keith Burns. Matt Martin’s covers are sick, but apparently he’s mostly known for Lady Death and cheesecake artwork when not immaculately detailing war planes haha

What you got?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s