Mister Miracle 1: Discussion

by Michael DeLaney and Patrick Ehlers

This article containers SPOILERS. If you haven’t read the issue yet, proceed at your own risk!

Michael: Jack Kirby’s Fourth World tales were weird, wild, and ultimately short-lived. In spite of this they have left a lasting impression on the DCU, inspiring later generations of writers to try to emulate the spirit of Kirby’s original saga. Jim Starlin, Grant Morrison and more recently Robert Venditti have shown us their take on The New Gods and now Tom King and Mitch Gerards add to the mythos in Mister Miracle 1.

For modern day comic books, superhero deconstruction is the name of the game. And what is more emblematic of superhero deconstruction than an opening sprawl of man in tights with slit wrists, bleeding out unceremoniously on a bathroom floor?

That’s a hell of an image to debut a comic book with. Mitch Gerards employs the classic 4 Color Process/halfdot coloring method to give Mister Miracle 1 an old-school vibe that looks as if it could’ve been published in Kirby’s time itself. Despite this opening spread and a few other full-page panels, the majority of the issue is adherent to the 3×3 panel layout — a favorite of both Gerards and King’s.

These kinds of layouts speak to us in a language of familiarity, so when we see a break in that pattern it stands out to us. One of the most frequent breaks in pattern are the black panels with the white lettering “Darkseid is” — but more on that later. It makes sense to have the same visual pattern with intermittent breaks in said pattern, as an extension of Mister Miracle himself. As Mister Miracle, Scot Free is the ultimate escape artist who subverts expectation and defies belief. These breaks in panel structure are akin to Scot breaking free from chains, deathtraps, or Darkseid himself.

Mister Miracle 1 is an interesting exploration of celebrity and mental illness wrapped in a Fourth World tale. The basic plot of the issue is that Scot Free is being rushed to the hospital after his wife Big Barda discovers him post-suicide attempt. Barda worries about Scot’s mental state while he goes on late-night talk shows and convinces the public that his brush with death was just his latest escape attempt. Meanwhile the war between New Genesis and Apokolips hits a boiling point as Darkseid has apparently gotten a hold of his coveted Anti-Life Equation, forcing Barda and Scot to join in the effort to stop him.

One of Mister Miracle’s most impressive feats is also one of his earliest ones: escaping Darkseid and the fire pits of Apokolips. As the legend goes, Highfather and Darkseid traded their respective infant sons Scot and Orion in order to broker peace between their worlds. Traditionally it seems that Kirby fancied the notion of “nature over nurture,” as Orion had his father’s characteristic rage and Scot had his father’s characteristic optimism — despite the environments they grew up in.

No matter how strong your biological ties may be however, I don’t believe that you can be raised in a hellish environment of hate and suffering without coming out on the other side with some mental scars. In general, Scot Free is a happy-go lucky man who has made the best out of a truly terrible situation. He’s a hero and a celebrity and has the love of his life. But as anyone who has had struggled with depression, anxiety, PTSD, or any other forms of mental trauma/pain can attest to, these “mental scars” are ones that live with you. For Scot, they manifest in the form of those “Darkseid is” panels I mentioned earlier.

King and Gerards don’t go into detail as to what Scot is thinking of in particular but I have no doubt that it is symbolic of the pain that his “father” Darkseid inflicted on him. And while we can all relate to having some form of past trauma haunt us and cause us to go to a dark place, not all of us have to “hold ourselves accountable” in the court of public opinion like Scot does. Was Scot trying to attempt “the ultimate escape” or was he trying to escape the pain that is Darkseid? I think the answer lies somewhere in between those two extremes.

While Mister Miracle 1 explores these real world ideas of trauma and celebrity, it is also a story about powerful gods that literally live on another plane of existence so there’s likely more going on than meets the eye. This is purely speculation of course, but I’d wager that Scot is trapped in some Inception-esque prison of Darkseid’s making.

Another interpretation of those “Darkseid is” panels is viewing them as Darkseid’s “reprogramming” of Scot Free. If Darkseid does indeed have the Anti-Life Equation, then he has the ability overpower men’s will — and Scot has the most indomitable will of all. Another hint of the “dream reality” is the talk show host Godfrey, who is most definitely Darkseid’s underling “Glorious Godfrey.” Godfrey taunts Scot with the idea that he might not have actually “escaped death” with his suicide attempt after all.

Mitch Gerards’ hazy colors and VHS-style TV presentation makes for a very dream-like reading experience. Add to that Scot’s “visions” of his old pal Oberon and his belief that Barda’s eye color has changed and you’ve got a credible “dream world” on your hands. My theory is that Darkseid doesn’t have the Anti-Life Equation yet and is somehow using Scot to obtain it for him a la Inception.

Patrick, what’s your take? I though Mister Miracle 1 was a lot of fun with some heady ideas that absolutely necessitate a second read-through. Do you have any insight on the dream-like quality of the book? Is Scot losing his grip or are there more surreptitious things going on? How much should we trust what we see in a book that focuses on an escape artist/master of illusion? What do you think about Orion showing up to just beat up Scot then BOOM-ing out? Is he just trying to be a tough guy? Do you think he believes Scot to be weak for attempting suicide?

Patrick: Your Inception-esque theories are interesting, but I think that ultimately sells short the experiences our boy Scott is in this issue. You’ll no doubt notice that I’m switching the spelling back to the double-t “Scott” instead of the Apokolipsian spelling of “Scot”. King uses this more common spelling throughout, emphasizing the humanity of the character over his superhumanity. Michael mentioned that the issue starts off with a spectacular splash page of Scott’s suicide attempt, but the real first page is much more muted, much more personal — an extreme close-up on Scott’s face.

We’re in close enough to see every single dot of Gerards’ old school color methods. This is accompanied by a bizarre narration that seemingly belongs to no one, and addresses the reader directly, posing exactly the kinds of questions Michael was posing earlier. “Is he a master of spectacular trickery or is he something more?” The narrator is acting as some kind of impossible hype-man, shouting at the readers to make some noise. But what those kinds of leading questions and aggrandizing statements miss are the vulnerable, human aspects of the character.

So I end up questioning the same parts of the issue Michael does, but I am less suspicious that Darkseid is the one pulling the strings. All of the audio visual glitches during the interview are a result of Scott trying to romanticize his suicide attempt — instead of slowly bleeding out on the floor of his own bathroom, he wants to believe that he was escaping a water-filled tube on live TV. The running commentary that accompanies the more fantastical version of his suicide attempt gives us some hints.

First of all, it’s worth noting that every one of these exclamation evokes the name of God. And again, we’re not totally clear on who is speaking these words. Is it the studio audience? Godfrey? Scott himself? The pages that follow offer no additional clues, as the closed captioned-style lettering refuse to assign speakers to individual lines of text. It is as though “the TV” is saying it. Those panicked violations of the third commandment are way too sincere, and way too personally invested to belong to someone watching what they know to be a stage show. Scott is taking either his own panic, or Barda’s upon discovering him on the bathroom floor, and imagining stunning an audience with an escape so spectacular that it gets the same response. He’s literally cinematizing his own life, trying to make sense of the narrative wherein his trauma gets the better of him and he makes an attempt on his own life.

Scott’s also in denial about the permanence of death. Not only does he envision it as something he can side-step to monstrous applause, he seems to be discounting its effect on others. Scott has an entire scene with Oberon — they shoot the shit about some Thanagarian cuffs, Oberon tells a joke, Oberon draws patiently on a big ol’ cigar. But Oberon’s been dead for weeks. The thing is, Scott totally knows this, and the reader has all kinds of clues that should lead us to that same conclusion. Here are the three biggest clues all in one panel.

There’s tape over Oberon’s eyes, just as there is in the other close-up panel Gerards draws of him. The effect is pretty unsettling, like the artificiality of the page is being emphasized, and the moment is forcibly pasted together. Oberon is also puffing on one of the cigars that we know killed him, the cause of his death face-to-face with the fantasy that he’s still alive. And lastly, there’s this question about the God joke. Has Scott heard it before? We have — the readers. That’s page four of this issue.

This is the issue’s orderly paneling at it’s most broken, but it’s also foreshadowing every other weird bit of imagery and trippy storytelling from later in the issue. Who is speaking? Oberon — a dead man? The child is also seemingly attached to the page with the same tape that covers Oberon’s eyes in the panel I posted above. And then the very last trippy thing — the piece of information I totally don’t know what to do with: the child has blue eyes. Is the child Barda? Or is Scott simply seeking the confidence of this child in his partner?

For a complete list of what we’re reading, head on over to our Pull List page. Whenever possible, buy your comics from your local mom and pop comic bookstore. If you want to rock digital copies, head on over to DC’s website and download issues there. There’s no need to pirate, right?


8 comments on “Mister Miracle 1: Discussion

  1. Credit where credit is due, if I was going to provide a watsonian explanation for why Rebirth is so bigoted, needlessly dark and generally crap, Darkseid finding the antilife equation is almost exactly what I would do…

    (The set up was too perfect. I couldn’t resist)

  2. I didn’t get any of this. I didn’t understand a single dingdong thing that happened. I found the comic unsettling, but not in story. More in… I felt like I sometimes do when I’m in a technical conversation and people are talking and using technological terms that only they know. They then come to a conclusion and look at me to nod approval. And I mutely do, not knowing if they know that I don’t have the fainest idea of what the hell they just said.

    Except here it’s who these characters are and what they’re doing. I didn’t get any of it. It was unsettling to read a maybe metaphor for suicide and not be in on the joke. It was unpleasant and not very fun.

    It’s possible that this was just a bit too much of a deep cut for me.

  3. Wonderful stuff. Too easy of a comparison, since were in a different medium, but this reminded me of episode #1 of Legion, after which I didn’t understand a damn thing. But i thoroughly enjoyed that journey and suspect I’ll enjoy this one, too.

  4. It was really good.

    @Matt, I’ve long thought the anti life equation infecting the DC universe before the first punch is even thrown would be a great story, particularly for the Movie universe.

    • Have you read Final Crisis? That’s basically how it begins, although in true Morrison fashion, it quickly gets much, much deeper and more complicated.

      And yeah, the release of the anti life equation would be a fantastic way to do a Darkseid movie, especially in the post-MCU world where you have to differentiate Darkseid from Thanks. Darkseid victorious in a world where evil has won, where DC’s heroes must be the last resistance , will instantly feel different to any Infinity Gauntlet story (on the other hand, if the rumours that Infinity War part 2 is actually going to be called Secret Wars is true, things will be much closer to an anti life story).
      Of course, this is all contingent on whether DC make a Darkseid movie. Apparently, the rumours are that they are scrubbing Darkseid from Justice League, trying to make Justice League as standalone as possible to avoid the need to ever acknowledge it again (the rumours coming out of Justice League are heartbreaking for anyone who wants a great movie. It really sounds like the production is a much larger mess than anyone could imagine, even after Snyder tragically had to leave). Which may mean that it will take forever to get a proper Fourth World movie.
      But if they ever do make that Darkseid movie, Final Crisis/Release of the anti life equation is the natural story

      • Right, but that was darkseid invading earth and taking over with the anti-life equation.

        I’d like it if it were like Darkseid has been hunting down the anti life equation and its been infecting the DCEU movies since MOS. So when he gets to earth he doesn’t want to destroy it, he thinks he’s home. Its a way to retcon all the dark stuff that’s been going on.

        Though if Flashpoint gets made, that will probably be the retcon route they take.

        Not sure if Justice league will be terrible, the same thing was said about Suicide Squad and Wonder Woman (which wound up having entirely different levels of critical success) So I don’t put much stock in the rumors yet. I think scrubbing the video game boss level darkseid stuff is wise. Put more time into making steppenwolf a villain and a character, rather than a stepping stone.

        • Honestly, I think Flashpoint is a better way to fix the DCEU than the anti life equation. Of DC’s options, they can choose to ignore MoS, BvS and Suicide Squad (I’m more positive on Suicide than most, when I try to read between the lines and see the original film. But the film he actually got is an all time disaster because of the horrific editing) and just make good movies in the Wonder Woman vein, or they can try to retcon everything.
          And if you are going to retcon everything, Flashpoint works a lot better as it erases everything that came before, and gives you a fresh start to tell these character’s stories properly. Because if you explain everything away with anti life, you then make the beginning of all your characters ‘infected by Darkseid’. I don’t think having ‘every moment of his career was under the influence evil’ is a good status quo to begin a new Superman movie. So either ignore the earlier movies and pretend there was something better in their place, or Flashpoint.

          And yeah, every DC movie had bad rumours and troubled production, but Wonder Woman had the calmest, which matters. Especially as the rumours of Justice League aren’t good. Two different directors filming two different tones. An exceptionally large number of reboots. Behind schedule (which is going to be a real problem with the effects. By now, FX should know exactly which shots they need to work on. Apparently, they don’t which will stretch them thin). There is a really good chance that this could be yet another editing nightmare from DC, especially as the balance of probabilities do not give hope (hell, Man of Steel is the only movie that doesn’t have major editing issues)

          I want Justice League to be a great movie. This year has been rich with great comic book movies, between Logan, GOTG, LEGO Batman, Spiderman, Atomic Blonde and the exceptional half of Wonder Woman (and Valerian is apparently a truly imaginative movie, but haven’t seen it yet. Only just came out here). I would love Justice League to join those ranks.

          Otherwise, I currently have a lot of faith in Aquaman. No production problems and everything I hear sounds right. Could be DC’s first truly great movie in the DCEU (though Wonder Woman comes close)

  5. I didn’t think there was that much to get really. Its just a guy almost dying and then waking up in a world thats subtly different. Classic Twilight zone.

    Apparently its based on Tom Kings real experience of a Panic attack and then feeling like all the things that happened after (Trump’s win, the Superbowl, etc) all feel like a strange new world.

    I think if this was a creator owned project it would be just as accessible.

What you got?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s