Shade, the Changing Girl 1

Alternating Currents: Shade, the Changing Girl 1, Drew and Michael

Today, Drew and Michael are discussing Shade, the Changing Girl 1, originally released October 5th, 2016. As always, this article containers SPOILERS.


Drew: Last week, I saw a program of animated shorts at a local film festival. I’ve always loved shorts, but seeing a dozen back-to-back highlighted just how effectively vastly different worlds could be established in just a few short minutes. This is especially true of animation, where the “rules” of the world — from its physics to the question of whether animals can talk — can often take unexpected turns. Indeed, I think discovering those rules is one of the joys of cartooning; examples from the shorts I saw include “oh, this is a world where a crow in a shirt and tie might become a young boy’s step-father” and “oh, this is a world where someone’s bomb shelter might be at the top of an impossibly tall tower“. That’s a joy that’s just as true of comics, and creators that take full advantage of just how weird their worlds can be often come up with something magical and unexpected. Cecil Castellucci and Marley Zarcone are clearly willing to go weird in Shade, the Changing Girl, and issue 1 suggests that they might be on to something very special.

(Full disclosure: while I’m reasonably familiar with latter-day Vertigo [100 BulletsY: the Last ManFables, etc.] I’m woefully ignorant of some of the imprint’s foundational series. I’ve read Sandman and have been slowly acquainting myself with Hellblazer, but I’ve never read any of Peter Milligan’s Shade, the Changing Man. I bring that up because its not clear to me how much of this weirdness to credit to Castellucci and Zarcone, and how much is building upon the rules Milligan established over twenty years ago. Ultimately, whether these rules are being resurrected, invented, or re-invented doesn’t really matter to my reading experience, but I wanted to put my comments in context for any die-hard Shade fans who obviously have a different context — I may dwell on long-established facts that are new to me, and may gloss over new, exciting changes that I fail to pick up on in this strange new world. I’m new here; bear with me.)

The weirdness starts from page one, and piles up remarkably quickly. We open with an apparent metaphysical take-over of a comatose girls body. That’s a concept we can at least get our heads around, though it establishes some important questions: who was this girl, and what is this force taking over her body? Those are both key elements to the series, but before any of those can be addressed, I also have to ask what’s with the all of the animals?

Zoo Hospital?

What is going on here? By the end of the sequence, the menagerie expands to include a few skeletons and a clown, all of whom seem to be physically engaging with their environments, toppling medical equipment, amusing children, and harassing orderlies. By the end of the issue, we have concrete answers to the origins of Shade’s mind and body — the mind is Loma, an alien obsessed with the original Shade; the body is Megan Boyer, a mean girl whose friends left her for dead after overdosing on pills — but these other oddities are never directly addressed, forcing a more metaphysical answer: they are manifestations of Madness, the force that allows Loma to posses Megan in the first place.

We don’t learn a whole lot about Madness, but we do get flashes of visions like this throughout the issue. I was particularly alarmed when Loma’s grip on reality seems to slip, turning the quaint Boyer family dinner into something much more macabre.


Loma’s relationship to Madness is clearly going to be a key source of tension as the series wears on — after this episode, she assures herself she’s in control — but I’m also curious how it affects the people around her. The patients and orderlies at the hospital seemed to see and feel the madness visions; do they manifest in real life, or can people just share in the visions?

Those questions may be central going forward, but this issue does a brilliant job of settling the questions of Loma and Megan’s respective lives. Megan’s “friends” are all nervous that she’ll remember what they did to her (she won’t), while Loma’s vaping boyfriend is fuming that she just used him to get to Rac Shade’s Madness vest. For all of the confusion about what’s going on with the metaphysics, it’s easy to overlook just how well-drawn those two lives are from just the few glimpses we get here, but we get just enough to flesh out the rest.

Oh, right: the Madness vest. This series clearly owes a debt to Milligan’s run, and Loma’s reverence of Shade might well stand in for Castellucci’s own. Body-snatching stories have themes of identity and attribution built in, but Castellucci has added even more wrinkles to that formula, having Loma actively trying to emulate Shade all while also trying to impersonate Megan. I suspect that’s a meta-commentary that will play even better to folks more familiar with Milligan’s run, but Castellucci’s respect for the source material is clear even to me.

Michael! This issue confused the hell out of me on my first read-through, but the more I think about it, the more I like it. Are you enjoying all of this weirdness, too?


Michael: Drew, I enjoy a healthy dose of weird in my comics so long as it doesn’t make the overall experience needlessly frustrating. And while there’s plenty of weird in Shade, the Changing Girl 1 I found myself understanding/enjoying it more than the only other “Young Animal” title thus far: Doom Patrol 1. In a way Shade, the Changing Girl 1 is playing on the sci-fi/fantasy high school metaphors that Buffy the Vampire Slayer did when it started out.

The basic idea of this book is “a creature from another dimension possesses the body of a teenage girl coma patient.” Without context this sounds like the premise for a sci-fi horror story, especially when the victim is a defenseless innocent like a teenage girl. As the issue progresses however we don’t feel as bad for Megan’s body being possessed by Loma because Megan was kind of a terrible person. As Drew pointed out, Megan’s mean girl clique is worried about her waking up because of their guilt about her coma. But I also think that they are just dreading the simple fact that Megan will be in their lives again. Similarly, the reaction that Megan’s parents have at the return of their daughter is sad and unsettling — they seem fucking scared.


While we’re being honest here, I’m also a rookie when it comes to the world of Shade, the Changing Man. Sorry. But the collective apprehension of Megan’s “friends” and family leads me to speculate a bit and compare Megan: normal teenage monster, with the Madness: reality-bending sweater vest monster. When Loma’s not in control, the Madness warps reality around her and everyday life turns into a bit of a nightmare fest.

I’m really leaning into this “sci-fi as high school metaphor” thing but couldn’t the Madness’ reality distortions also be symbolic of Megan’s “awakening”? It’s been five months and the world that Megan knew has changed: her boyfriend is dating another friend of hers, the clique itself seems to be thriving and Megan’s parents have come to the difficult (?) decision to pull the plug and say goodbye to her. The specter of Megan returning to their lives has essentially shifted their reality, everything is changing again. Megan’s parents become skeletons at the dinner table — dead inside from feelings of guilt, fear, and probably overwhelming debt in medical bills.


Maybe it’s because we’re very familiar with the “mean girl” stereotype or because we’ve personally seen groups like that in high school but these aspects of Shade, the Changing Girl 1 seemed to really speak to Drew and I. I really like the ideas of social power and group mind that Castellucci, Zarcone, and Hernandez explore here. The swim team clique is a hive and at one point Megan was a Queen Bee who ruled with fear. Though their Queen is gone Zarcone shows that the clique is still a hive mind in a panel that, for me, begged comparison to the “precogs” in the film Minority Report. Even if that wasn’t the intended reference, the way they are literally putting their heads together to plan a cover story is a great visual.

The last thing I’ll touch on is Loma herself. Another reason I don’t think that Shade, the Changing Girl 1 reads like a body-snatcher horror book is because Castellucci doesn’t write Loma as a threatening alien figure. She’s not inhabiting the body of a teenage girl in order to accomplish her evil agenda — as far as we know — she’s just trying to run away from her problems. Loma is the Meta version of the 20/30 something who doesn’t know what the hell she’s doing with her life so she looks to her favorite artists. It’s just in this case her favorite artist happened to be in possession of a reality-bending technicolor dreamcoat — er, vest.


For a complete list of what we’re reading, head on over to our Pull List page. Whenever possible, buy your comics from your local mom and pop comic bookstore. If you want to rock digital copies, head on over to Comixology and download issues there. There’s no need to pirate, right?

4 comments on “Shade, the Changing Girl 1

  1. The interesting thing about Mean Girls is that the ‘viewpoint character’ actually has a weird backstory. We think of viewpoint characters as ordinary, but Cady is a homeschooled kid who spent most of her life in Africa alongside zoologist parents. Not ordinary, but exactly the sort of outsider needed to look into high school cliques. And that is what Shade the Changing Girl does so well.

    I complained that Doom Patrol’s viewpoint character was too weird, but that was because a weird person is the worst outsider viewpoint for Doom Patrol’s weirdness. But here, we have a weird outsider exploring the ordinary dynamics of high school. And it really works. Seeing the swim team, or the parents try and deal with the fact that Megan’s back really works, given the distance to observe and to look from the outside – reminds of the Vision. Looking from an outsider’s perspective (helped by the fact that they don’t understand that this isn’t Megan), we see a new side. The swim team is especially interesting, as their actions take a slightly sinister vibe. They have been wronged and hurt, but there is also a sense that they may have started down the path of the new Megan. Michael’s comparison to a hive is great, and there is a very clear sense that there is a new Queen Bee who is just as controlling.

    Meanwhile, there is the madness itself. A book like this doesn’t lend itself to one-to-one metaphor. Instead, the Madness is likely going to be applicable to a range of experiences, morphing into different meanings depending on the context (quite perfect, for something as random and chaotic as the Madness). I think there are going to be too major sides. Firstly, Loma’s relationship with the Madness, which is a literal extension of her own issues. Even before putting the vest on, Loma had problems with obsession and self control, and the Madness is a manifestation of those problems threatening to consume her. No wonder the book ends with her thinking she has it under control when, just behind her, a giant mouth is about to eat her.

    But what I’m really interested is what the Madness will mean for everyone else. Because they won’t see Loma, or anything like that. They’ll see Megan. What will their reaction be to Megan’s return, as she deals with the Madness? I think it will be very revealing. Really happy with this

  2. What does everyone think of DC’s strategy with Young Animal and now Wildstorm? It is great that DC are drawing attention and making a big deal about their experimental work, in a way that Marvel don’t (we all love the Vision, but that book exists as just one of many Marvel books). DC are using these imprints to announce books that Marvel just couldn’t. Young Animal is currently a mixed bag, with Doom Patrol as a disappointing start and Shade looking good, but Cave Carson has a Cybernetic Eye seems like it could be really interesting (and has the best name ever) and I think Mother Panic is going to be really interesting, as I think it is going to subvert our expectations. Meanwhile, an Ellis run Wildstorm Imprint sounds like an amazing idea.

    But while I like them championing the new and interesting in some part of their publishing line up, I’m not sure how I should interpret two new imprints announced in one year. Is this supposed to be a statement of intent? Because while I love the sound of both of these imprints, I would love it if DC could announce something interesting without saying that they had launched a new imprint to support it (I saw their announcement of a new Batwoman book, just as I was complaining about their lack of queer content. Made me feel like I just made a wish with a cursed Monkey’s Paw)

    • I think the thing that’s perplexing to me is that Young Animals is borrowing so much of Vertigo’s cachet — Doom Patrol and Slade, the Changing Man were both members of Vertigo’s inaugural class — which makes me wonder why they didn’t just run these under the Vertigo imprint. Part of it may be that I don’t totally understand the structure of Young Animals; while Vertigo had virtual autonomy under Berger, DC recently moved take a more hands-on approach to the imprint, forcing Shelley Bond out. Oddly, Bond is now editing the Young Animal books, though the specifics of the editorial hierarchy aren’t entirely clear. The press releases call it a “pop-up” imprint, and quote DiDio and Lee with no mention of Bond. Indeed, the press releases emphasize Gerard Way’s involvement, suggesting that he’s “curating” the line, though apparently not as the editor of any of the books.

      Assuming Bond has as much control over these books as she had over Vertigo (or, at least, as much as she would have had under the new “DiDio directly oversees Vertigo” paradigm), why not launch these as Vertigo books? The history is there. The tone is right. Even the language in the press releases refer to Young Animal as a “mature reader” imprint.

      Two related guesses: 1) the Vertigo name had lost so much cachet over the last few years that DC decided to apply their love of relaunches to the very idea of the imprint. 2) Bond in particular had lost her cachet after a series of false starts with new series, so was publicly ousted from Vertigo and very secretly kept on Young Animals to keep doing what she’s always done. Either way, the move seems to be returning Vertigo to its roots, they’re just not calling it “Vertigo” and are also being oddly cagey in revealing who exactly is in charge.

      • Young Animal is certainly a return to Vertigo’s roots, but I don’t think the reason Young Animal exists is that Vertigo has lost so much cachet. I think it is the fact that Vertigo has changed. I mean, you just admitted that you are ignorant of a lot of Vertigo’s foundational series, but familiar with Fables, Y: The Last Man and 100 Bullets. These days, Vertigo is DC’s creator owned imprint, and is represented by Original Series like American Vampire, Clean Room and Sheriff of Babylon. Before Hellblazer was cancelled, even that had done everything it could to pretend it wasn’t part of the DC Universe (and by that same logic, I don’t believe the current Lucifer book, a Sandman spinoff, is acknowledging the fact that it is in the DC Universe either).

        With Vertigo so completely different, I’m not surprised they decided a new imprint would do a better job at representing what Vertigo used to. Let modern day Vertigo be modern day Vertigo, and let Young Animal be what Vertigo used to be. The exact roles of Gerard Way and Shelley Bond, however, I have no idea. Though it is weird that they make such a big deal of Gerard Way and Warren Ellis doing what you would think are editorial roles

What you got?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s