Marvel Round-Up: Comics Released 10/19/16

marvel-roundup53

We try to stay up on what’s going on at Marvel, but we can’t always dig deep into every issue. The solution? Our weekly round-up of titles coming out of Marvel Comics. Today, we’re discussing Amazing Spider-Man 20, Astonishing Ant-Man 13, Black Panther 7, Black Widow 7, Captain America Sam Wilson 14, Death of X 2, Doctor Strange 13, Patsy Walker AKA Hellcat 11, Silk 13, Spider-Woman 12, Unbeatable Squirrel Girl 13, and Uncanny Inhumans 14 — and come back on Friday for our discussion of Infamous Iron Man 1, on Monday for our discussion of Mockingbird 8, and on Wednesday for our discussion of Mighty Thor 9! As always, this article contains SPOILERS.

slim-banner4

Amazing Spider-Man 20

amazing-spider-man-20

If I was giving one piece of advice to writers starting a new series? Have a second think about doing the “here is unexpected scene, then skipping back in timeline to show how you got there” opening. Obviously it can work brilliantly. We all know the work we’re aspiring to when we do it… but it feels that 50% of books use it. I think there’s a fun analysis of why writers like it so much. I think it’s partially about insecurity in our own material. As in “Honestly — this gets really interesting. See how wild this gets? Now stick with me, and we’ll get there.” And there’s a “I want to really strike people in the face” part of it to the opening of a new work. But there’s obvious big problems… Primarily removing tension from the book and almost certainly blowing your best idea on the first page, meaning the rest risks being flat.

Kieron Gillen

Drew: I’ve seen the cold-open flash-forward critiqued a lot over the years, but Kieron Gillen sparked a fascinating conversation on twitter last month when he tweeted those statements, prompting dozens of creators to weigh in on the issue. That conversation — and especially Gillen’s opening volley of tweets on the subject — were on my mind as I read Amazing Spider-Man 20, an issue that so suffers from that flatness Gillen describes, it’s a wonder anyone thought its story was even worth telling.

The issue opens with Spider-Man in the grips of a resurrected Otto Octavius, but quickly flashes back to just after the destruction of the Living Brain, with Otto’s consciousness now inside a Superior Spider-Man gantlet/octobot. These are all details we already know — the location of Otto’s consciousness was explained in Amazing Spider-Man 18, and his corporeal return was revealed at the end of Clone Conspiracy 1, meaning this story is really about filling in gaps to a story we already can more-or-less guess. Indeed, the line from Otto-as-octobot to Otto-as-clone is so direct, it might have been just as satisfactorily explained in a couple of lines of dialogue.

That’s not to say writers Dan Slott and Christos Gage don’t come up with a few surprises, just that those surprises ultimately don’t matter. Take, for example, the metaphysical face-off between Otto and Peter’s consciousnesses inside Otto’s clone brain. There’s not a lot of tension to be mined from that scene, since we already know Otto will be menacing Peter in just a few days, but the bigger problem is that Slott and Gage don’t invest in the stakes, either.

Control

This sequence is frustratingly unclear. At first reading, I thought Otto was simply banishing Peter with a thought. On closer inspection, I can see that Otto used his dismembered robot arms to impale Peter, but then it’s less clear why he asserts the importance of it being his body. Would he have been able to do that otherwise (and if so, why hasn’t he)? If not, and he has godlike powers over this fight, why bother fighting at all?

But like I said, these questions are mostly irrelevant, and only fall out of a question nobody asked. I still have faith the Clone Conspiracy will turn out to be a fun event, but this issue is its “Jack’s Tattoos,” spinning wheels to bring us the origins of details none of us bothered to even question.

slim-banner4

Astonishing Ant-Man 13

astonishing-ant-man-13Spencer: To call Scott Lang a screw-up would be an understatement. Writer Nick Spencer points out in Astonishing Ant-Man 13 — the finale of his run with Ramon Rosanas and Brett Schoonover — that Scott’s greatest strength as a hero is that he never stops trying, but within the very same issue we see that Scott’s instincts are frequently wrong. Scott nearly makes an ill-advised, illegal deal with Beetle (who just wants to shrink too, bless her crooked little heart), and Cassie herself points out how misguided his attempt to take the fall for her is; sure, Scott never stops trying to do right, but he almost always misjudges what right is.

That’s why the grand climax of this series comes when Scott is forced to reevaluate his relationship with Cassie. Actually, that goes for both her parents: Cassie’s mother, Peggy, finally accepts that she’ll never be able to stop Cassie from being a hero, while Scott realizes that she’s always been a better hero than he’ll ever be.

my-hero

Cassie is the reason Scott became a hero in the first place and, even now, she’s still his motivation, but the context behind that has changed. Scott’s no longer trying to “protect” Cassie by lying to her, vanishing from her life, or even going to jail for her. Instead, he wants to live up to her expectations and example by being the best hero, father, and partner he can be. That partnership — Ant-Man and Stinger, Scott and Cassie — is such a beautiful thing; both have so much to learn from each other. The Lang family is finally healthy, and it looks like Scott is finally making some smart decisions. I guess all it took for Scott to grow up was accepting that Cassie had grown up as well.

slim-banner4

Black Panther 7

black-panther-7Ryan D: Black Panther 7 starts us off with a bang, offering a very nice respite from the openings of past issues which often began with an internal monologue from the titular character; this time, however, we get a tussle resulting from Ezekiel Stane’s bunch of baddies throwing hands with the arriving cavalry consisting on Ororo Munroe, Misty Knight, Luke Cage, and Manifold — “the Crew”. This fight, while entertaining in a superhero-y kind of way, also showcases some very interesting dialogue.

blackpanther7-1

I should not be surprised that a writer like Ta-Nehisi Coates could give me so much food for thought from a punch-up as the conflict turns from a “good guy vs. bad guy” altercation into a fight of black heroes against a villain perpetuating the Eurocentric racism of White Man’s Burden. Particularly interesting is the use of appropriated language, as the heroes banter about the use of the word “thug”– a word much maligned in recent media coverage of black protests in the US — and “kaffir” — an ethnic slur for black Africans of which I had no knowledge before reading this issue. Both times these controversial words are used, the heroes end up reclaiming them for their own uses, offering a very metaphorical, overarching battle as the fisticuffs take place.

Coates splits his narrative again between three different lines: firstly, T’Challa and his struggle against Stane, then the scholar Birnin Azzaria as he meets with the super-powered leaders of The People’s resistance movement, and also Shuri on the spiritual plane. While it can always be risky for an author to shift focus so much during a story, I found that it worked well in this issue. I love especially how the use of folk tales runs parallel with the main plot, and illustrates the deeper knowledge which it seems all of the other characters talk about but never really achieve. On the other side of the coin, we see the the resistance fighters who, until now, always kept a shade of ambiguity about them in the sense that they were never really condemned as villains from the artistic team. Coates wrote this splinter cell without judgement, leaving the audience to make up their own mind; at this point, though, the ideological lines in the sand have been drawn, proving that this student-mentor conversation might actually have been a notable volta for Zenzi and Tetu’s philosophical standpoint.

Issue 7 comes across as a very focused, deliberately written, and thoughtful comic. If you are still interested in the fight for the heart and mind of a nation on a micro and macro level with some fun cameos, dig on in. It seems like things will be ramping up in a big way soon.

slim-banner4

Black Widow 7

black-widowPatrick: There are a precious few comic book artists that are as good at using traditional paneling as meaningfully or as effectively as Chris Samnee. A lot of the more acrobatic visual storytelling in comics will play with the shape and definition of panels to sell motion or atmosphere or tone, but for Black Widow 7, Samnee adheres to a maniacally strict set of standards for his layouts — all right angles, black gutters for the real-time pages, white gutters for the flashback pages. This all serves to express Natasha’s character, which similarly insists on precision. My favorite line from this issue — and I’d love to know whether to credit it to Samnee or his co-writer Mark Waid — sums this up perfectly: “never use a chainsaw when a scalpel will do.”

The precision of this surgical storytelling is also established so thoroughly so the reader will inherently panic when Samnee pulls the rug out from under us. There’s this bravura sequence where the Weeping Lion is trying to psychically extract memories from the Headmistress, only to have the whole thing interrupted when the Headmistress shoots herself in the head.

Headmistress' Memories

This is a sole moment of visual chaos, suggesting all sorts of tantalizing secrets and plans, and it’s the only time that Samnee breaks all of his own rules, even taking the abstraction far enough to make the Headmistresses’ head the gunshot itself. It’s such a cool way of turning a terrible moment into a totally catastrophic one.

slim-banner4

Captain America Sam Wilson 14

captain-america-sam-wilson-14Drew: I don’t make a habit of watching Comedy Central’s roasts, but let me describe one thing that I’m fairly certain has never happened: as soon as the first joke is told, the target of said joke leaps up to decry how unfair it is that only they are being picked on. This doesn’t happen because 1) everyone understands that making fun of people is precisely the point of roasts and 2) everyone also understands that everyone will get theirs, even if only one person can be targeted at a time. As unreasonable as that fictional roastee is, I’d like to suggest that this is exactly how certain readers responded to the opening arc of Captain America: Sam Wilson, where Sam confronted a group of vigilante border patrollers. If only they’d bothered to hang around to issue 14, they’d see that writer Nick Spencer is just as happy to target wingnuts on the left as he is those on the right.

This month’s wingnut is Flag-Smasher, a terrorist with a plan borrowed from Project Mayhem: blow up whatever institutions he feels are “enslaving” humanity. Flag-Smasher’s goals aren’t entirely unappealing — Rick Jones has to remind himself whose side he’s on — but his methods are not something Captain America can stand for.

bombs

Literally holding (members of) the government hostage to achieve his goals may sound more like the Tea Party than anyone we associate with the left, but I’ve seen enough leftist ideologues wonder if we wouldn’t be better motivated to fix things if Trump wins to see the parallels. Those ideologues and Flag-Smasher both want only exactly what they want, democracy be damned.

To drive home how counterproductive that attitude is, Spencer reveals that Flag-Smasher is actually working for Hyrda (or, rather, that the Flag-Smasher we see in this issue is actually a LMD puppet used by Hydra to enact its own agenda). I’m sure anyone on the left refusing to vote for Hillary would balk at the claim that they’re effectively supporting fascism, but if the end result is the promotion of a fascist ideology, do the words that justify it even matter? It reads as a rather harsh criticism of third party voters/conscientious objectors to this election, but also plants Sam as firmly in the middle of the Marvel Universe’s political spectrum. He may be left of Steve, sure, but you guys heard that Steve’s a member of Hydra now, right?

slim-banner4

Death of X 2

death-of-x-2Patrick: I think we tend to give a little too much credit to obviously articulated analogies. The more parallels between fictional characters and current events, the “ballsier” the satire, right? I know I’ve blinked dumbly at the screen while South Park takes a public figure to task using their real name, likeness and actual ideals. And that’s certainly brave — criticizing someone directly means you could be inviting retaliation — it’s not the most artful exploration of those topics. That’s actually been one of the greatest strengths of the X-Men franchise, which has this perfect metaphor for all excluded people in the form of mutants. Are they gay? Racial or religious minorities? Are they guns? An over-militarized police force? The X-Men are flexible enough to be their own, relevant to today’s issues without having to adhere to specific issues. That’s what Charles Soule and Jeff Lemire have channeled in the excellent second issue of Death of X.

The conflict between the Inhumans and the Mutants is demonstrated very early on in the issue, through a one-on-one interaction between Medusa and Storm. Storm’s got some X-Men lackies waiting on the landing pad, and Medusa’s an easy Facetime call away from having the RIV get her back, but essentially, it’s down to just these two women. It’s a delightfully simple interaction – they both hear each other, and they are both willing to accept the best intentions of the other. Artist Aaron Kuder plays up Storm and Medusa’s visual similarities — leaning on their distinct hairstyles — to underline their ideological similarities.

the-hair

There is a very serious, life-or-death problem at the heart of this, but these two women are appealing directly to each other’s rationality. Cyclops, meanwhile, nukes it all by appealing to everyone’s — and I mean, fucking, everyone in the world — fear and distrust. He uses Emma and the Cuckoos to broadcast a reactionary message of hate and hostility around the world instantaneously, like it’s some kind of hyper-Twitter. I am a long-time Scott Summers backer, but this is the first time I’ve been able to see his revolutionary tendencies weaponized so recklessly. And once again, I’m forced to ask the question of what is the specific metaphor here? Is Cyclops Trump – drumming up support on Twitter? Or is he a Gamer Gate agitator with a large following on Reddit? Perhaps the only message here is that, with a big enough audience, emotional outbursts can be declarations of war.

slim-banner4

Doctor Strange 13

doctor-strange-13Taylor: The thing that’s often forgotten about Doctor Strange is that he’s actually a doctor. Before he dove into the world of magic, Stephen was a promising young MD who saved people with his hands and his mind. Of course, we all know that a horrible accident to his hands quashed these dreams and send Stephen on his well-known path, but it’s interesting to wonder what would have happened if things were different.

This “what-if” scenario is exactly the stuff that dreams, or in this case, nightmares, are made of. Stephen has been pulled into a nightmare by, well, Nightmare, his old adversary. There, things seem perfect for Stephen. His hands are healed and he is a world-famous surgeon with enough cash, cars, and sex to satisfy any number of dreams. But this is all too perfect and Stephen quickly realizes he’s in a trap and turns the tables.

This is an unremarkable nightmare story. It’s basically the same plot almost all nightmare stories take on, so in some ways this issue is a bit pedantic. However, the climax of the story, where Stephen realizes how to defeat Nightmare, is actually quite fun. In the clutches of his enemy, Stephen realizes that all he has to do to defeat Nightmare is use the same principles he learned in med school and apply them to magic.

doctor-strange-md

These three panels are essentially a remix of the three panels that open the comic. The only difference is that instead of cutting into a human body, Strange is now cutting into the fabric of magic. This moment comes after we’ve seen Strange living a life of ease and prestige and is therefore more poignant than it would be in isolation. Just like when Stephen rejected Mordo’s offer to fix his hands for giving up magic, once again Stephen chooses a more difficult path all so he can travel the magic path. What makes this especially meaningful is that he’s able to do this while still using the same set of skills he uses in his dreams as a surgeon.  Even though this is not an outstanding issue of Doctor Strange, Jason Aaron finds a way to still keep it meaningful.

slim-banner4

Patsy Walker AKA Hellcat 11

pasty-walker-aka-hellcat-11Ryan M.: Part of what makes Patsy Walker such a refreshing character is her basic goodness. She’s been through challenges, but her natural instincts make her a positive force in the lives of her friends. That’s why Kate Leth’s choice to set up Black Cat as a foil works so well in Patsy Walker AKA Hellcat! 11. Black Cat doesn’t have some deep grudge against Hellcat, just some basic curiosity with a dash of jealousy. For her, that’s enough to recruit a team of trouble-makers to “disappear” Hellcat.

The Black Cats have satin jackets and bad attitudes. They are modern hipster punks, who combine posturing with disregard for others. When you compare them to Patsy’s friends in the city, you see that Leth has given us two sides of the same coin. When Ian and Bailey met Hellcat, they were minor criminals, but all it took was encountering her goodness for them to join her. The Black Cats are what happens when you want adventure but you have no regard for other people.

Meanwhile, in the midst of the usual adorable shenanigans and the introduction of Black Cat and her crew of jerks, we have a very realistic disagreement between Ian and Patsy. She encourages him to use his powers to fight bad guys and doesn’t pick up his discomfort until he abruptly ends their conversation to leave. It’s such a relatable exchange. Patsy didn’t know Ian’s boundary until she tripped over it. It’s also a fairly minor tiff, but both characters are thrown into a funk. Patsy mopes on rooftops in full Hellcat garb while Ian lounges on the couch singing along to the most painful parts of Hamilton.

make-upThe series is about friendships and sometimes friends inadvertently hurt each other. And, just like in real life, an honest conversation can solve a conflict between people who love each other. It’s a sweet moment, reinforcing that Patsy’s greatest power is her goodness.

slim-banner4

Silk 13

silk-13

“What’s next?”

Traditional

Patrick: There’s bound to be a time in the life of every young superhero where their story rubs against the fundamental conflict that created them and drives them to heroism. Silk 14 casually (but very sweetly) reunites Cindy with her parents, effectively concluding the largest on-going conflict in her life. Writer Robbie Thompson and artist Tana Ford play this casual sweetness for all it’s worth, giving the reader glimpses into the quiet, happy versions of their lives before Cindy was bit by a radioactive spider. Ford sets up this page three times, always using the same 4-panel layout, the first three delivered washed-out, saccharine images of the past, and the fourth snapping back to the action-packed present. By the third of these pages, the format is as comforting as the images themselves, and the detached, past-tense narration makes it clear that Cindy is relaying these events from a place of comfort. It’s a therapy session, but we don’t see the shape of that scene until everything is said and done.

It’s fascinating to see much of the bombastic action in the Negative Zone waved off for the slower family non-drama that surrounds it. The issue’s title page would suggest that we’ve got some kind of nasty battle between dragons and demons and knights to look forward to.

silk-title-page

But instead, Ford focuses on the hugs, the memories, the gentle assurance that everything’s going to be okay. That’s exactly why it starts to feel weird – toward the end of the issue we join Cindy and her doctor mid-session, and left with only the words and feelings, something feels off. I love this page – the first two panels show Cindy and her doctor close together, but the third and fourth panels literally keep them separated, and the angle of the final panel has forced real distance between them in the same room.

cindy-in-therapy

It’s that question – “What is next for you?” – that makes Cindy feel alone.

slim-banner4

Spider-Woman 12

spider-womanSpencer: In Spider-Woman 12, writer Dennis Hopeless combines three of the series’ strongest ongoing themes — the joys/demands of family, the more mundane side of being a superhero/villain, and the ongoing rehabilitation of the Porcupine — into one absolutely charming one-off tale. Roger’s battle against the Sandman gives the issue a fairly standard set-up, but it stems from uniquely Spider-Woman circumstances: Sandman’s trying to relax after a heist gone wrong, new parent Jess now has to schedule her relaxation time and won’t give it up for anything, and both situations force Roger to step-up.

Hopeless continues to be bluntly realistic in his depictions of the challenges of parenting, and not just when it comes to the demands on Jess’ time.

baby-danger

This moment made me gasp. It’s not commented on again, but it’s still a grim reminder of how careful Jess needs to be now. In a way, it’s refreshing that Hopeless doesn’t sugarcoat parenting, but it’s just as refreshing that he doesn’t demonize it either. Much of the joy of this issue comes from seeing Jess, Roger, and their kids bond as a makeshift family — Jess even mothers him about sunscreen at one point — and likewise, Roger’s biggest reward for saving the day isn’t the respect of Jess or even his increased confidence in himself, but the adoration of his young daughter. What could be greater?

Artist Tigh Walker is an essential component of this issue. Not only does his work emphasize the affection between these characters as much — if not more — than the writing, but his focus on detail and background characters brings each and every scene to life.

live-baby

Seriously, Walker never settles for a generic dull pose or lifeless character. Gerry could just be a prop here, but instead he struggles and climbs all over Jess as any baby might. It adds so much life to the proceedings, and in a book that thrives on life and connection, that touch is essential.
slim-banner4

Unbeatable Squirrel Girl 13

unbeatable-squirrel-girl-13Spencer: The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl is a dense book. It’s rare to see a panel without copy, and that’s because Ryan North, Erica Henderson, and Rico Renzi want to cram as many jokes as humanly possible into every nook and cranny — heck, this month I laughed out loud before I even finished the recap page! That’s why I was surprised to see several significant silent — or near silent — sequences throughout issue 13. Fortunately, they’re just as funny as any of the best constructed jokes.

brain-drainAdmittedly, much of the context for this gag comes from the panels preceding it — which explain that Brain Drain is taking a photo of sensitive information Ant-Man foolishly left open on his computer — but so many of the visual details alone here make me laugh. There’s the fact that Brain Drain is using a flip-phone in 2016, that he takes the photo with the front-facing camera instead of the normal one, the way the second panel lights up with the phone’s flash while Scott just snores through it all, even just the fact that Brain Drain is daintily holding Scott’s shrunken bedroom aloft throughout the entire sequence. My favorite detail, though, is the mask that’s fixed in place on Brain Drain’s helmet, even as his eyes move around inside it. The image of Drain peeking beneath the mask in the first panel, only to stare intently through the mask in the second, had me in stitches.

There’s a similar gag on the next page — where Brain Drain just ejects himself from a jet instead of bothering to land it — that plays out just as well, but the other dialogue-free sequence I wanted to highlight comes a few pages later, and, oddly enough, doesn’t contain a single joke!

silent-boating

This is a simple, rather standard establishing shot, yet it feels really effective. It’s a moment of peace after a few tense confrontations, and it’s a moment of reflection that prompts Doreen and Scott to attempt to get to know each other better. Perhaps most importantly, it highlights the alien qualities of Squirrel Girl‘s Canada — moments this quiet and serene are rare within this book’s usual world.

I’m not complaining about Squirrel Girl‘s joke ratio — the book is absolutely riotous, and this issue is no different — but it is nice to change things up now and again. This issue is a great example of how to make a few small, effective changes without losing a book’s identity, and I love it all the more for it.
slim-banner4

Uncanny Inhumans 14

uncanny-inhumans-14Drew: Last month, I praised Uncanny Inhumans 13 for establishing and following three blocs of characters with three distinct motivations and perspectives, setting up a conflict I compared to Tom Clancy’s The Sum of All Fears. As much as I love the conflict of that story, I have to admit its resolution isn’t the most thrilling: Jack Ryan averts disaster with a phone call. That resolution flips the story from a political action/thriller to a character study — a flip that works when the narrative is understood as part of the Jack Ryan universe, but doesn’t make for a particularly satisfying conclusion in a vacuum. That Uncanny Inhumans is an ongoing comic series certainly makes its larger context more important, but I’m afraid it doesn’t prevent the resolution from being a bit deflating.

Writer Chalres Soule knows how to keep the tension high, but since we know that Stark’s beef isn’t actually with Medusa, it’s hard to sustain the conflict with those two players. Instead, this issue focuses on the Inhumans trapped in New Attilan — Inhumans who fight not because they believe the lie Stark is responding to, but because they feel they need to defend their queen and country. From that perspective, the characters truly shine. Karnak gets to be a skilled warrior and tactician, but admits that he’s no leader. Iso gets to step up and inspire a successful revolt against Stark’s drones. Triton gets to have his crisis of conscience, rejecting Maximus and aiding in Iso’s uprising before ultimately turning himself in.

Triton

These are smart choices that build upon these characters as we know them, but it also relegates Medusa to the background. When she finally does show up, her conflict with Tony is resolved with such a short conversation, you can’t help but wonder why she didn’t take a page from the Jack Ryan playbook and just call him. This issue is perhaps best read as a pause in Medusa’s promised hunt for those responsible (though Triton’s admission makes it clear now who she’s hunting for). I suppose such unexpected hitches in personal agendas is routine for a sovereign, but shifting momentum from issue to issue is a little jarring for the rest of us.

slim-banner4

The conversation doesn’t stop there, because you certainly read something that we didn’t. What do you wanna talk about from this week?

Advertisements

One comment on “Marvel Round-Up: Comics Released 10/19/16

  1. Amazing Spiderman: I think I’m mostly commenting on Amazing Spiderman to have an excuse to post this

    Which is of course written because Dan Harmon, just like Kieron Gillen, understands what an overused crutch that idea is. In fact, while Gillen is right about removing tension and flatness, there is another problem that he ignores. By using another part of the script to create an interesting beginning, you are giving yourself an excuse not to actually have the beginning interesting. In general, Gillen is right.

    But (from my perspective as a guy who unfortunately does not enjoy Slott’s work despite liking his ideas, and so doesn’t read Spiderman), I think there may be another problem. If the main story is in Clone Conspiracy, what is supposed to be told in Amazing Spiderman? The most interesting parts of the Doctor Octopus stuff was written during the build up or in the main series, and Amazing Spiderman can only fill in the blanks. It reminds me of some of the Avengers tie ins Bendis wrote to events like Secret Invasion. The big problem with this approach to tie ins is twofold. Firstly, filling in the blanks is rarely an interesting narrative. Secondly, the need for the Clone Conspiracy to stand on its own means that every important blank must be in the Clone Conspiracy itself. Which leaves Amazing Spiderman with nothing that important to actually do. Which, just as Drew said, leaves you with a situation that could have been explained in a couple of lines of dialogue. When a character is sufficiently central to an event (like Spiderman is to Clone COnspiracy) it can be nearly impossible to make a satisfying tie in, because everything important is literally in the main event book.

    And this in no way indicts Clone Conspiracy, or suggests it won’t be a great event. But maybe it shouldn’t have had its own miniseries.

    ______________________________________________________________

    Black Panther: I spend a lot of time thinking about action sequences. In comics, action is one of the examples where visual storytelling really has to be pushed. Meanwhile, literally every storytelling tool, from structure, to momentum to whatever else you can think of, needs to be applied. Otherwise, you have a series of panels which are just people punching in different ways. Which creates the problem with this issue.

    I was positive on the last issue, but here I feel that Ta-Nehisi Coates’ weaknesses really catch up with him. Coates’ problem is that his ultimate work is less than the sum of its parts, and that is really felt here. Is it interesting seeing the Black Heroes quip about reclaiming slurs? Yes. But the fight has very little structure. Turnabouts happen, yet a never really felt. Partly because the dialogue does a bad job at showing a change, partly because once Luke Cage counter attacks, it feels like there is a return to status quo, and partly because there seems to be no rhyme or logic to it. We have Coates’ recurring problems. THere is a long list of great ideas. Black Heroes v White Man’s Burden. Black Heroes reclamation of slurs. Black Panther fighting a man with an Iron man suit under his skin with his hands tied behind his back. And yet a fight scene acts as the perfect demonstration of Black Panther’s flaws. Every idea Coates has is amazing, and yet the storytelling still eludes him, unfortunately.

    With the right kind of work, this scene could have been amazing. Begin by treating each scene as a story by itself, a story that with a beginning, a middle and an end that also acts as a beat for the issue as a whole. Understand all the different threads running in the scene. The Crew fighting the People. Black Panther fight Stane. The thematic discussion. Stane’s reevaluation of his position. Work out what happens in each thread (Coates is fantastic at the thematic discussion part, as that is the closest to what he is familiar with. But the Crew’s fight could have more effort into structuring events so that each beat feels like the natural progression of the beat before, instead of ‘lots of things happen in a fight scene’). And then, with every panel, try and progress as many threads as possible. Keep track of all your elements, and don’t let important elements disappear (like Vanisher did, who turned the fight against the Crew, but then disappeared instead of being dealt with, leaving the Crew to regain control of the fight simply by his absence. He only reappears when Stane needs him. What would have been more interesting is for the Vanisher to still be involved when Stane called him. Maybe the Vanisher was losing, or was doing his best to hide from the Crew as they turned their attention on him and he had to play defensively. Maybe he was still winning, and yet Stane called him off because of T’Challa successfully beating Stane)

    But that is the hard thing. The allegory continues to be the part Coates does the best, and Changamire’s scene with Tetu and Zanzi is a great demonstration of why they are villains, despite their noble goals (the fact that Zanzi would happily use her powers on Changmire is very telling), but turning all those great ideas that Coates had, whether it is a great theme, a great beat or a great discussion, into a narrative is something that Coates is still struggling with. And this issue’s focus on fight scenes act as a major example of the problem.

    ______________________________________________________________

    Sam Wilson, Captain America: Captain America and Captain Fascist team up! But after last issue, I keep getting the two of them confused.

    Leaving aside my truly massive problems with Sam Wilson’s actions last issue, this is a great issue. I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again. Steve Rogers as a HYDRA operative is fun in the exact way that a good horror movie is fun. Seeing the monster stalk our heroes so successfully is fantastic to read. Especially as in this case, the sheer political nature of the book means that Steve’s manipulations are so much more interesting. Tricking Banner into restarting dangerous Gamma Experiments is great, but manipulating the media and taking advantage of political turmoil to get the nation to eat Sam alive is so great. Especially when you also get to enjoy Steve tying the knot on a loose end.

    And looking at the ways that Flagsmasher’s ultimately well meaning ideals are turned to fascism is fantastic. I, like most of the characters of the book, understand the racism inherent in the No Fly List. But I also understand that progress in a democratic society must come from those with a mandate from the entire society (unlike, say, Sam Wilson’s actions last issue, where he made himself the sole arbitrator of morality). Flagsmasher isn’t just doing Fascism’s work by being a robot that exists to manipulate public perception against Sam Wilson. He is doing Fascism’s work by both legitimising violence as political expression and discrediting his own ideology through his use of terrorism.

    And it is not hard to see real world parallels. Not only are there the ideologues who want Trump to win so that he can burn everything down to make people understand (which is stupid for a hundred different reasons). Early in the election cycle, I remember similar ideologues discussing the need for actual violent action to defeat Trump.

    I’m basically just repeating the same thing Drew did and going a little deeper, but Drew is right. Honestly, I think this is the best issue of Sam Wilson yet.

    Also, I kind of want Steve Rogers to be HYDRA forever. There is so much entertainment available in having such an important character subverting everything.

    ______________________________________________________________

    Doctor Strange: The story of this issue is a complete cliche. The perfect world that Strange could have had if his origin never happened. And as a cliche, it is the sort that really works to a formula.

    But what really interested me about this one was the emphasis on the bad. Aaron has given us a Doctor Strange whose eating habits is a tragic cost, not a culinary choice. And that idea permeates throughout this issue. So often, this story’s many iterations are different only in the coat of paint, but the choice to focus on Strange’s disgusting diet, on the horrors of what he did in the cellar, and his hands show a slightly different approach to the bad stuff than this story usually has.

    In fact, the same word that he uses to describes these terrible things is the same word that defines him. Strange. To him, the bad stuff is not just the cost of living his life as the Sorcerer Supreme, but part and parcel of it. Which fits Aaron’s depiction of Doctor Strange. A depiction whose major trait is that good or bad, he is always on the side of the weird. The bad parts of his weird life are just as important to him as the good parts.

    And the ending also addresses this in a clever way. The What-if scenario is a ‘What should have been’. What should have happened, if he didn’t have the car accident, didn’t damage his fingers. He should have been a surgeon. And yet, in the end, he affirms that even in his weird life, he is still a surgeon. He never lost that when he lost his hands. He just changed his patients

    ______________________________________________________________

    Patsy Walker: I honestly didn’t care for the Black Cat stuff. In all honesty, it is a bit too similar to the first arc’s villain, with the Patsy subverted vibe. We had that.

    The real interesting stuff is with Ian. It is honestly a little more than Patsy accidentally crossing a line. Ultimately, Patsy has accidentally let herself treat Ian as a bit of a sidekick. That isn’t to say that she is nasty, but her assumptions about Ian are a mistake that builds into a greater idea of this arc. Ian has a life outside his life with Patsy.

    And that is what Patsy is going to have to navigate. She has a great friendship with Ian, but so far, everything dramatic has been about her. Ian has supported her with her business, with her issues with Hedy, with her issues with her exes, and now Patsy is going to have to do the same. She is going to have to help Ian with his. Whether it is respecting Ian’s boundaries or helping with his ex, she is going to support Ian just as Ian has supported her

    ______________________________________________________________

    Spiderwoman: This issue was basically simplicity done to perfection. A simple idea of Jessica trying to take a day off, and Roger having to step up. I love that they avoided the obvious route and have Jessica step up out of some responsibility nonsense. I have said it before and will say it again, ‘With Great Power COmes Great Responsibility’ is the most important theme of any superhero comic. But in giving herself days off and training Roger to take her place when she is resting is the most responsible thing to do.

    But yeah, what else is there to say? The characters are animated, the relationships are strong. The little beats are amazing (Spencer, I too loved the beat of Gerry reaching for Jessica’s energised hand). Roger’s heroism is deftly portrayed by his ability to take a beating for twenty minutes and still get up, even as he forgot his flash cards. Each and every element comes together to be perfect. This continues to be one of Marvel’s best

What you got?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s