All-New X-Men 17

Today, Taylor and Shelby are discussing All-New X-Men 17, originally released October 2nd, 2013. This issue is part of the Battle of the Atom event. Click here for our complete coverage of Battle of the Atom.

atom divider

Taylor: Hey, do you guys remember 2008? Specifically, do you remember when Barack Obama was elected president? It was big moment and not solely because it decided who would be the most powerful man on the planet for the next four years. For the first time, a black man was elected to the highest office. Some said it happened sooner than they expected, others as it not having come soon enough. Regardless of the stance, there’s no denying that it was a watershed moment for the United States and one that brought a certain amount of hope for the future with it. Suddenly, instead of being a backwards country who only elected the white and rich, America was viewed as progressing in the right direction. But the glossy sheen of hope fades fast and in these days of bitter bipartisanship and government shutdowns the hope that once surrounded Obama’s administration is now lost. There are those who stand staunchly by our embattled president and those who have become jaded by the world altogether because Obama didn’t live up to their impossibly high expectations. In this fallout, what is left for these individuals? Do they rally to change the system or become mired in hate and malice? All-New X-Men 17 ponders this question along with the usual time travel paradoxes.

In the future (…at some point in time), Alison Blaire, aka Dazzler, runs for president as a mutant. She pulls off the unthinkable and wins. This finally seems like the moment when humans and mutants will live together in harmony. However, as she is giving her victory speech she is assassinated when dozens of dragons… or something… attack. Future-Beast is angry about this and it seems pretty clear he now wants to kill all humans. In the future-future, past-Ice-Man, Magik, and Past-Beast meet the real future X-Men and convince them to help their past selves battle Future-Beast and the fellow Un-X-Men. Back in the past — which is really the present –Cyclops and company are licking their wounds from battling the Future Un-X-Men when the real Future-X-Men arrive to lend them a hand.

The latest installment of the Battle of the Atom takes a noticeable shift in tone that is both needed and refreshing. Previously, the event had focused almost exclusively on time travel and the weird things that can happen when you meet your present or past self. In this issue, however, we begin to focus on motivation. Specifically, we begin to understand what motivates some of the mutants from the future and thereby can begin to formulate their reasons as to being in the past.

That being said, I found the parallels between Alison Blaire’s election and Barack Obama’s 2008 run to be almost endless. Given the way artist Stuart Immonen portrayed these scenes, it would be hard to argue that we are supposed to think anything otherwise.

I guess  the government restarts...years from now.

We all remember the Obama campaign’s singular theme of “HOPE” and that theme is certainly echoed here. However, whereas Barack got the chance to see his ambition and hope struck down by punitive Republicans, Blaire is struck down by a literal thunderbolt before she even gets the chance to take office. In both cases, the sense of hope that once pervaded the election of a minority to president is soon replaced by anger and frustration. For Future-Beast this seems to be the final straw in his effort to bridge the gap behind human and mutant peacefully. What his plan is, and why he traveled to the past with some Un-X-Men is unclear, but it seems like his reason is nefarious at best.

Perhaps totally coincidentally, this issue is that it’s being dropped on us just as the government is being shut-down for what may be a long time. We generally elect people to office to run our country so when they don’t do that people get angry and frustrated with politics. You would be hard pressed to find someone still clinging to Obama’s HOPE given these circumstances, and it’s startling how well this feeling is echoed in this issue. Future-Beast, with his hopes dashed in so many dragon-smashed bits, is a man disillusioned and unsure of something he once believed in staunchly. For any of us who once believed in the Obama campaign’s mantra of “HOPE” we can surely sympathize. Of course, writer Brain Michael Bendis couldn’t have planned this parallel on purpose (unless he’s time traveling…which maybe…) but perhaps he is trying to capture the general dissatisfaction the average American is feeling with politics these days. If that’s the case, I am pleasantly surprised.

Lest you tire of all of this talk of politics, fear not, for there is still amount of time travel goofiness contained in this issue. Ice-Man is on a roll throughout the issue and I’m sure Drew will be pleased that Colossus’ ‘stache is not spared Bobby’s snark in the verbal fray. However, what I appreciated most was Bobby confronting his future-wizard-self.


Just what is that hulking Ice thing sent into the past from the future? Apparently Future-Wizard-Ice-Man can make them. He would tell his past self how to do it, but you know: PARADOXES. I could go into more detail but perhaps Shelby has more to say on the matter. Do you Shelby? Do you think we’ve finally met some future X-Men we can trust? Who do you think killed Alison Blaire? Could it be someone from a different time?

atom divider

Shelby: It could ALWAYS be someone from a different time; that option is never off the table. But I have some rather complicated suspicions; when this event first kicked off, Cyclops’ team and Kitty’s team faced off trying to recruit a new mutant, a gal who could summon dragons. That seemed like more magic than mutation, and a weird way to jumpstart a time travel event, but now I’m seeing some connections. Assuming she’s behind the attack, regardless who is on what side, this future is still a time of mutants fighting mutants. So, Xorn et al traveled back to the present to send the past X-Men (specifically Young Jean) to their own time in order to prevent poor Dazzler’s entire election and demise? Was the aftermath of that day so bad they felt it justified breaking time (again) to undo it? There is still the small matter of things looking pretty okay with the actual Future X-Men: is this more a matter of Xorn and the Un-X-Men taking unnecessarily drastic steps in the face of a loss to try to get their own way? Steps that could ultimately cause more long-term harm than the good they claim to be fighting for? Taylor, maybe the comparison to the current state of the government in the US is more apt than you realized.

Despite the fact that this story continues to get more and more complicated, I’m still enjoying this event immensely. I love the drama Bendis is laying out, and with only four issues left to go, I can really feel the tension building before the big conclusion. Stuart Immonen’s art is beautiful as ever. The spread of Dazzler’s death is beautiful and shocking; the inset panels convey the sudden chaos as everything happens at once. Even with all that going on, Immonen makes sure to make time for a slender panel of Dazzler’s shocked face and Beast’s tears.

dezzler's demise

Despite the drama and terror happening on the page, Immonen makes time for small moments of emotion, and the same can be said for Bendis. For every dramatic plot twist, we get Colossus’ metal mustache and ice wizard Bobby. Really, just some fine mutant facial hair all around. I love seeing more future versions of characters we know; if Phoenix Force Quentin Quire doesn’t scare the crap out of you, I don’t know what will. I know the whole, “Twists! Betrayals! I laughed! I cried!” schtick sounds pretty tired, but I mean it in the best possible way. This event is meaningful, suspenseful, and fun to read; I honestly have no idea how things are going to turn out, and I can’t wait to find out.

atom divider

For a complete list of what we’re reading, head on over to our Pull List page. Whenever possible, buy your comics from your local mom and pop comic bookstore. If you want to rock digital copies, head on over to Comixology and download issues there. There’s no need to pirate, right?

15 comments on “All-New X-Men 17

  1. Such a fun issue! Loved Magick’s and Colossus’s brother-sister moment, super-saiyan-haired Quentin, Jubilee taking on the mantle of Wolverine, Tony Stark rocking a new Skeletor version of his helmet and, what, did he discover that he’s a mutant too? Excuse me, I have to go breathe into a paper bag, there is way too much awesome going on in here.

    Taylor – if you had to choose between having Colossus’s ‘stache and Iceman’s beard, which would it be?

    • My favorite thing about his mustache is that it’s so distinctively NOT Russian. Colossus doesn’t give a shit. Colossus does what he wants.

    • Oh man, Quentin Quire as the Phoenix was terrifying! I guess it makes sense that he’d be able to actually tame it – he’s such a miserable sarcastic asshole that it really can’t take advantage of his sensitivity or vulnerabilities. Still, that dude with that power seems like reason enough to avoid this future.

  2. I still don’t buy Beast’s turn even at a moment like this. One of the problems I have with a lot of future stories how nothing has to be earned narratively. The fun of seeing non-version future heroes seems to be enough to satiate folks.

    This story which I was enjoying a lot, took a dip for me with part five and this issue is digging deeper. The more I see what is behind some of the mysteries presented the less interesting the story is getting and more we are loosing focus on what the story is actually about, Scott and Jeans freedom of choice vs greater good.

    What should be a natural story built off of a ludicrous character narrative premise (beast brings back the original X-men to cheer folks up and convince Scott he is being a jerk) is getting undermined by a flood of characters who bring little other then over complication to the story.

    This story should be playing out between the current X-men, the original five, and Scotts uncanny team. All the pieces to resolve this story and highlight or give insight into the characters that matter are contained in those three groups.

What you got?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s