The Futility of Definition in Inhumans: Judgment Day 1

By Patrick Ehlers

This article contains SPOILERS. If you haven’t read the issue yet, proceed at your own risk!

Reading any on-going comic is an exercise in accessing memory. If a writer, or an editor, is feeling particularly generous, there might be a note on the page to jog that memory a bit. Can’t remember what’s up with Karnak? Don’t worry, an editorial note has that addressed. Can’t remember what Swain’s power is? A narration box has your back with a one-word explanation: “Empath.” But these characters are too complex for that, right? Al Ewing’s Inhumans: Judgment Day 1 explores the limits of definition as it applies to a cast of characters that is both constantly changing, and constantly changing back.

Ewing plays with this concept from the minute his characters are introduced. The first Inhuman we see is Flint — a character in the process of changing.

“Geokinetic” explains what Flint can do, but is it definitive? Swaim and Panacea don’t seem to think so, as this new crystal arm adds wrinkles that defy that definition. He’s a living creature, and much like Medusa and Black Bolt’s relationship is harder to nail down with a single word or pithy phrase.

Of course, defining the Inhumans as “indefinable” would be a bit of a cop-out, to say nothing of hypocritical. That’s why Ewing leverages the unending smart-assery of Maximus. Maximus is already a living example of these characters’ mutable natures, having just shifted from “the Mad” to “the Mage.” But he’s also the jackass who tries to leverage everyone’s need for definition to his advantage, making up the word “floob” so he can get Reader to spirit one of them to the astral plane to fight the Progenitors. The amazing thing is that it actually works, sending Medusa into a Mike del Mundo-fueled astral odyssey where she experiences “ten thousand years” of wandering in the desert with Black Bolt. That messianic journey helps Medusa shake the confining definition of “wife of Black Bolt,” while also allowing her buck the label of “dying.”

That’s the crazies part, of course: we have to know that Medusa’s hair would return eventually. In rejecting one definition, she’s really re-embracing another. Mind you, it’s an advantageous definition, so y’know, good for her.

The conversation doesn’t stop there. What do you wanna talk about from this issue?

One comment on “The Futility of Definition in Inhumans: Judgment Day 1

  1. Does this comic really reject the definition of Medusa as ‘Black Bolt’s wife’? I read this because apparently Black Bolt will cross over with it, and I have to say that it felt like the complete opposite. For all the superficial elements of change, ultimately this is Ewing reiterating the same beats everyone else has. The simple truth of this issue is that no matter what they say, everything is always the same (I’ve saw some pages of Royals from other issues that just made clear that Ewing can’t write Noh-var, even in the far future, as anything but as a guy completed obsessed with one girl he dated and one song he listened to in his young adult times, which completely misunderstands Gillen’s depiction of him in Young Avengers. There is no growth, there is no change. There is just trivia).

    Ultiamtely, this is a comic where Medusa gets her powers back/wins the fight/asserts her identity by promising to return to Black Bolt. The superficial elements are different, but ultiamtely, Medusa only becomes Medusa again when she dedicates herself to being in Black Bolt’s orbit again. She is and always will be confined to her original definition, with no chance to grow or break free, no matter how defining it is. And if she doesn’t, she loses her hair/identity.

    It is no wonder this issue ends by showing that the supposed death was not actually a death. In the end, everything is enslaved to be exactly what it was like before. To change and to evolve is to go against the very vision of this issue

What you got?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s