All-New Wolverine 32 finds Catharsis in Revenge

by Drew Baumgartner

All-New Wolverine 32

This article contains SPOILERS. If you haven’t read the issue yet, proceed at your own risk!

This issue opens with a heartbreaking flashback sequence chronicling the simultaneous loss of innocence for two young girls. One is Amber Griffen, whose father was killed at his first day on the job protecting a presidential candidate. The other is Laura Kinney, who was the assassin sent to kill that candidate (and anyone else within clawing distance). Years later, it’s easy to understand why these women would be enemies, but Tom Taylor and Djibril Morissette-Phan take care to demonstrate that Laura is every bit as victimized by these events as Amber, telling their stories in parallel to drive that point home.

Amber and Laura

It’s a sequence that only gets more heartbreaking as it drives towards its inevitable conclusion, as these two stories tragically become one. It’s a bravura way to set up the conflict of this issue, as Amber and Laura head off to find the Neo-Nazi that organized the hit in the first place.

Of course, exactly what they plan to do with him is very much up in the air.

Laura's morals

Laura’s position here is fascinating to me. She’s doing everything she can not to kill this guy, but she’s not going to insist that Amber do the same. This isn’t a hero that’s going to ram their “no killing” rule down their allies’ throats — she’s just not going to partake in the killing. It suggests a comfort with death and revenge that I can’t quite get my head around, though it’s fortunately a moot point, as Amber ultimately opts not to kill Nazi dude.

What Amber does do, though, is take Laura up on that invitation to bring some Nazi-stomping boots. In what must be the best moment of the issue, Amber and Laura don those boots together to exact a little bruising revenge on their way to actual justice. Only, the image we see isn’t of the adult Amber and Laura — it’s the two of them at the age they were in the opening flashback:

Amber and Laura again

In this way, Taylor and Morissette-Phan can imply catharsis — the closing of that wound that opened years ago — without having these characters just say what they’re feeling. Maybe “catharsis” is the wrong word — it could just be that the young girls we meet at the beginning of the issue are finally getting the revenge they so desperately wanted. Either way, it’s a powerful image that works beautifully as a response to this issue’s opening pages.

The conversation doesn’t stop there. What do you wanna talk about from this issue?

One comment on “All-New Wolverine 32 finds Catharsis in Revenge

  1. Honestly, taking one of the most iconic moments of Laura’s origin, and showing it from the perspective of the child of one of her victims is such a genius idea. The way both stories are shown in parallel to show the true scope of the pain inflicted is amazing, showing both Laura and Amber greatly hurt, by different reasons. Maybe the middle section of this issue is a bit loose and weak, but the sheer strength of that start is makes that ending so powerful.

    You talked a lot about the catharsis of the ending, but the other clever thing it does is that it ties the Orphans of X story to a close thematically. Instead of judging the Orphans of X for their focus on catharsis over justice, it reconciles the pain by finding he healthy middle ground. One where catharsis and doing the right thing can come hand in hand.

    Also, it feels kind of weird to see Nazis involved in that assassination, as the threat of Nazis of politics is such a contemporary problem. And yet, the original story is from 2007. AN interesting example of how Comic Book Time unmoors a stories from a specific time and they turn into a gestalt of all the different time periods’ concerns.

What you got?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s