De-Romanticizing War Stories in Poe Dameron 29

by Patrick Ehlers

This article containers SPOILERS. If you have not read the issue yet, proceed at your own risk!

This arc in Star Wars Poe Dameron has been all about telling war stories: who does it, and why they do it. The answers thus far have been pretty straightforward. Poe tells Rey and Finn what he was up to during The Force Awakens so they can bond over their differing perspectives on a shared experience. It brings them closer together. And Artoo and Beebee honor their fallen droid brothers by recounting the serial number of every robot lost in the attack on Starkiller Base. These are noble war stories, and that’s weirdly consistent with the tone of the original trilogy. For as much as Star Wars was about Vietnam, Lucas perhaps didn’t have the historical perspective to capture the tone or cadence of war stories from that conflict. With Poe Dameron 29, writer Charles Soule taps into a sense of hopeless, confusion and pointlessness, rounding out his list of reasons to tell war stories with one of the hardest explanation out there: because they happened.

The issue starts by testing Poe’s capacity to even hear Jessika’s story in the first place. He pauses the playback and appeals to Threepio “tell me I’m not watching Jess’ last words here.” It’s a valid concern, and also not one that Threepio is able to assuage. We’re already seeing a different effect of storytelling here — instead of stories bonding characters, or letting them remember their fallen friends, this one threatens to do psychological damage to our hero. Poe wrestles with this for a moment, before resigning himself to his duty and hearing out the rest of the story. Luckily, Jess demonstrates that she’s just as good a bringing Poe joy as she is at crushing his spirit.

I love this moment because it’s the last time the issue reminds the reader that there is an audience for this story. Poe’s reaction is a simple “heh,” but it’s a perfect character beat, showing both his ego and his affection for his friend’s gentle ribbing.

From that point on, though, Soule and artist Angel Unzueta stick to the content of Jessika’s story, which is messy. Black Squadron knows they’re being tricked, and essentially allow themselves to be used by a not-so-benevolent bug-king. This isn’t a story that makes us laugh, or that makes us fondly remember acts of heroism. But it’s also not really helpful in any tactical way — only teaching a lesson that cannot be universally applied. The moral seems to be “sometimes, people will take advantage of you.” Which is horrifying, and the messy, non-heroic, non-romantic version of war is finally present in Star Wars.

For a complete list of what we’re reading, head on over to our Pull List page.  Whenever possible, buy your comics from your local mom and pop comic bookstore.  If you want to rock digital copies, head on over to Comixology and download issues there.  There’s no need to pirate, right?

2 comments on “De-Romanticizing War Stories in Poe Dameron 29

  1. I haven’t read the issue yet, but looking at the art of Poe’s Heh, are you sure it is about ego and affection? It looks a little awkward, which makes a lot of sense given Poe’s arc in the Last Jedi.

    This is a Poe that has been humbled, a Poe that has realised that his crazy egotism wasn’t heroic but wildly irresponsible, and has grown into a more mature person after realising that fact. If you asked Poe post-Last Jedi about Poe’s plan to take down the dreadnought, I think Poe would be the last person who would say things about being the ‘best pilot in the galaxy’. He’d care more about how stupid and irresponsible it was.

    Is Poe hehing because it is a playful joke about his egotism, or is it an expression to an unintentionally awkward reminder of the man he used to be but, after the events of Last Jedi, isn’t anymore? Personally, the art doesn’t make Poe look comfortable, which makes me feel it is the latter

    • Sure – could be a mixture of things right? He might have an uncomfortable relationship with his own hot-shot-ism, but that’s all still buried in her personality. No matter what has transpired since he last saw Black Squadron, he’s watching a message from his friend who made a joke razzing him pretty good.

      But you’re right – I might be misreading Poe’s reaction there. But I think the important part of this scene is that Poe is reacting. He’s the audience for the story, instead of being the one telling it. I’m eager to see what lessons, if anything, he learns from Jess’ story. Are these stories meant to teach anything?

What you got?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s